Highly Dissatisfying

Well at long last me and Mexican Dave took the PP AWI rules out for a spin at the club last night. The rules were familiar to us as we've played quite a few ACW games with the sister set, but I cant put a finger on it but these AWI ones just didnt cut the mustard. Even with Dave's dice rolling being its usual crap it was all too one sided, bayonet charges were far to easy to pull off and quite literally 9 times out of 10 the unit being charged didnt hang around to actually fight but routed as soon as the charge started. Think I'll stick with Civil War Battles and maybe re-jig the AWI armies to be used with Black Powder.